Skip to content
EMDR International Association
  • About EMDR Therapy
    • Learn more about EMDR
      Therapy

      Find an EMDR Therapist®

      What is EMDR Therapy

      AIP Model

      AIP Model

      Experiencing EMDR Therapy

      Experiencing EMDR Therapy

      EMDR in Treatment Guidelines

      EMDR in Treatment Guidelines

      Recent Research

      Recent Research

      Uses for EMDR

      Addiction

      Addiction

      Anxiety

      Anxiety

      Childhood Trauma

      Childhood Trauma

      Depression

      Depression

      PTSD

      PTSD

  • About EMDR Therapy
    • What is EMDR therapy?
      • Adaptive Information Processing (AIP) Model
      • EMDR Therapy & Addiction
      • EMDR Therapy & Anxiety
      • EMDR Therapy & Childhood Trauma
      • EMDR Therapy & Depression
      • EMDR Therapy & PTSD
    • Experiencing EMDR Therapy
    • EMDR Therapy in Treatment Guidelines
    • Recent Research on EMDR Therapy
    • Find an EMDR Therapist®
  • Training & Events
    • EMDRIAâ„¢ Training and
      Events

      EMDRIAâ„¢ Conference
      EMDRIAâ„¢ Virtual Summit

      EMDR Basic Training

      Eligibility Requirements

      Eligibility Requirements

      5 Steps to EMDR Training

      5 Steps to EMDR Training

      EMDR Basic Training FAQs

      EMDR Basic Training FAQs

      Training vs Certification

      Training vs Certification

      Find EMDR Basic Training

      Find EMDR Basic Training

      EMDR Education Calendar

      Consultant / Trainer Events

      EMDRIA OnDemand Education

  • Training & Events
    • EMDR Basic Training
      • Eligibility Requirements for EMDR Basic Training
      • 5 Steps to Take an EMDRIAâ„¢ Approved EMDR Basic Training
      • EMDR Basic Training FAQs
      • Training vs Certification
      • Find an EMDR Basic Training
    • EMDR Education Calendar
    • Continuing Education
      • OnDemand Education
    • EMDRIA Conference
    • EMDRIA Summit
      • Summit Speaker Resources
    • EMDRIAâ„¢ Digital Badges
    • EMDRIA Certified Therapistâ„¢ Application
      • How to Market Yourself as an EMDRIA Certified Therapistâ„¢
      • EMDRIA Certified Therapistâ„¢ FAQs
      • Membership vs Certification
      • EMDRIA Certified Therapistâ„¢ Renewal
    • EMDRIA Approved Consultantâ„¢ Application
      • Updating EMDRIA Approved Consultantâ„¢ Standards
      • CIT Declaration Form
      • EMDRIA Approved Consultant in Trainingâ„¢ FAQs
      • EMDRIA Approved Consultantâ„¢ Renewal
      • Consultant Day Events
    • EMDRIA Credit Provider & Program Applications
    • EMDRIA Approved Trainerâ„¢ Application
    • EMDR Basic Training Policies & Requirements
    • Standards for EMDR Basic Training
    • Trainer Day Events
  • Credentialing
    • Puzzle

      Credentialing

      Apply: Certified Therapist
      Apply: Approved Consultant
      Apply: Approved Trainer

      EMDRIA Certified Therapistâ„¢

      Membership vs Certification

      Membership vs Certification

      Certification FAQs

      Certification FAQs

      Certified Therapist Renewal

      Certified Therapist Renewal

      EMDRIA Approved Consultantâ„¢

      Updating Consultant Standards

      Updating Consultant Standards

      CIT Declaration Form

      CIT Declaration Form

      Consultant-in-Training FAQs

      Consultant-in-Training FAQs

      Approved Consultant Renewal

      Approved Consultant Renewal

      EMDRIA Approved Trainerâ„¢

      EMDR Basic Training Standards

      EMDR Basic Training Standards

      Training Policies & Requirements

      Training Policies & Requirements

      EMDRIA Credit Providers

      Program Application & Guidelines

      Program Application & Guidelines

      EMDRIA Credit FAQs

      EMDRIA Credit FAQs

      EMDRIA Digital Badges

      Consultant / Trainer Events

  • Publications & Resources
    • Publications & Resources

      Search the EMDRIA Library
      Subscribe to our Blog

      Journal of EMDR Practice & Research®

      Go With That Magazine®

      Focal Point Blog

      Let's Talk EMDR Podcast

      EMDRIA Library

      Glossary of EMDR Terms

      Glossary of EMDR Terms

      Online EMDR Therapy Resources

      Online EMDR Therapy Resources

      Antiracism Resources

      Antiracism Resources

      Toolkits & Practice Resources

      Toolkits & Practice Resources

      Español: Recursos en Español

      Español: Recursos en Español

  • Publications & Resources
    • EMDRIA Library
    • Glossary of EMDR Terms
    • Antiracism Resources
    • Online EMDR Therapy Resources
    • Focal Point Blog
      • Subscribe to Focal Point Blog
    • Go With That Magazine®
    • Journal of EMDR Practice & Research®
    • Let’s Talk EMDR Podcast
    • Toolkits & Practice Resources
      • 8 Phases Toolkit
      • Building Your EMDR Practice Toolkit
      • Client Brochures
      • Addictions Toolkit
      • Depression Toolkit
      • EMDRIA Children’s Toolkit
      • Chronic Pain Toolkit
      • Military Toolkit
      • EMDR Consultation Toolkit
    • Kits y Recursos Prácticos
      • Folletos de Terapia EMDR
      • Kit de las 8 Fases
      • Kit de la Depresión
      • Kit del Dolor Crónico
      • Kit de los Niños y Niñas
  • Membership
    • Users_Group

      Membership

      Member Hub
      EMDRIA Member Connect

      Join EMDRIA

      Benefits of Membership

      Benefits of Membership

      Membership vs Certification

      Membership vs Certification

      Agency Group Membership

      Agency Group Membership

      International Affiliates

      International Affiliates

      Members Only

      Account Overview

      Account Overview

      Directory Profile Information

      Directory Profile Information

      Renew Membership

      Renew Membership

      Retired Membership

      Retired Membership

  • Membership
    • Join EMDRIAâ„¢
      • Retired Membership
      • Agency Group Membership
      • International Affiliate Organizations
    • Member Hub
    • Renew EMDRIAâ„¢ Membership
    • Membership Benefits
    • EMDRIAâ„¢ Member Account Overview
    • Directory Profile Information
    • Membership vs Certification
  • About EMDRIAâ„¢
    • Circle_Help

      About EMDRIAâ„¢

      EMDRIA Foundation

      About Us

      EMDRIA 30th Anniversary

      EMDRIA 30th Anniversary

      Policies & Code of Conduct

      Policies & Code of Conduct

      EMDRIA Awards & Winners

      EMDRIA Awards & Winners

      EMDRIA FAQs

      EMDRIA FAQs

      Meet the Board of Directors

      Board News and Updates

      Board News and Updates

      Contact Media Relations

      Contact EMDRIA

  • About EMDRIAâ„¢
    • EMDRIA’s 30th Anniversary
    • EMDRIAâ„¢ FAQs
    • Contact EMDRIAâ„¢
    • Contact Media Relations
    • Board News and Updates
      • Annual Membership Meeting
    • EMDR International Associationâ„¢ Policies
    • EMDRIAâ„¢ Awards & Winners
    • EMDRIA Foundation
FacebookTwitterLinkedinInstagramWordpress
  • Join EMDRIAâ„¢
  • Contact
  • Find an EMDR Therapist®
EMDR International Association
Log In
  • About EMDR Therapy
    • Learn more about EMDR
      Therapy

      Find an EMDR Therapist®

      What is EMDR Therapy

      AIP Model

      AIP Model

      Experiencing EMDR Therapy

      Experiencing EMDR Therapy

      EMDR in Treatment Guidelines

      EMDR in Treatment Guidelines

      Recent Research

      Recent Research

      Uses for EMDR

      Addiction

      Addiction

      Anxiety

      Anxiety

      Childhood Trauma

      Childhood Trauma

      Depression

      Depression

      PTSD

      PTSD

  • About EMDR Therapy
    • What is EMDR therapy?
      • Adaptive Information Processing (AIP) Model
      • EMDR Therapy & Addiction
      • EMDR Therapy & Anxiety
      • EMDR Therapy & Childhood Trauma
      • EMDR Therapy & Depression
      • EMDR Therapy & PTSD
    • Experiencing EMDR Therapy
    • EMDR Therapy in Treatment Guidelines
    • Recent Research on EMDR Therapy
    • Find an EMDR Therapist®
  • Training & Events
    • EMDRIAâ„¢ Training and
      Events

      EMDRIAâ„¢ Conference
      EMDRIAâ„¢ Virtual Summit

      EMDR Basic Training

      Eligibility Requirements

      Eligibility Requirements

      5 Steps to EMDR Training

      5 Steps to EMDR Training

      EMDR Basic Training FAQs

      EMDR Basic Training FAQs

      Training vs Certification

      Training vs Certification

      Find EMDR Basic Training

      Find EMDR Basic Training

      EMDR Education Calendar

      Consultant / Trainer Events

      EMDRIA OnDemand Education

  • Training & Events
    • EMDR Basic Training
      • Eligibility Requirements for EMDR Basic Training
      • 5 Steps to Take an EMDRIAâ„¢ Approved EMDR Basic Training
      • EMDR Basic Training FAQs
      • Training vs Certification
      • Find an EMDR Basic Training
    • EMDR Education Calendar
    • Continuing Education
      • OnDemand Education
    • EMDRIA Conference
    • EMDRIA Summit
      • Summit Speaker Resources
    • EMDRIAâ„¢ Digital Badges
    • EMDRIA Certified Therapistâ„¢ Application
      • How to Market Yourself as an EMDRIA Certified Therapistâ„¢
      • EMDRIA Certified Therapistâ„¢ FAQs
      • Membership vs Certification
      • EMDRIA Certified Therapistâ„¢ Renewal
    • EMDRIA Approved Consultantâ„¢ Application
      • Updating EMDRIA Approved Consultantâ„¢ Standards
      • CIT Declaration Form
      • EMDRIA Approved Consultant in Trainingâ„¢ FAQs
      • EMDRIA Approved Consultantâ„¢ Renewal
      • Consultant Day Events
    • EMDRIA Credit Provider & Program Applications
    • EMDRIA Approved Trainerâ„¢ Application
    • EMDR Basic Training Policies & Requirements
    • Standards for EMDR Basic Training
    • Trainer Day Events
  • Credentialing
    • Puzzle

      Credentialing

      Apply: Certified Therapist
      Apply: Approved Consultant
      Apply: Approved Trainer

      EMDRIA Certified Therapistâ„¢

      Membership vs Certification

      Membership vs Certification

      Certification FAQs

      Certification FAQs

      Certified Therapist Renewal

      Certified Therapist Renewal

      EMDRIA Approved Consultantâ„¢

      Updating Consultant Standards

      Updating Consultant Standards

      CIT Declaration Form

      CIT Declaration Form

      Consultant-in-Training FAQs

      Consultant-in-Training FAQs

      Approved Consultant Renewal

      Approved Consultant Renewal

      EMDRIA Approved Trainerâ„¢

      EMDR Basic Training Standards

      EMDR Basic Training Standards

      Training Policies & Requirements

      Training Policies & Requirements

      EMDRIA Credit Providers

      Program Application & Guidelines

      Program Application & Guidelines

      EMDRIA Credit FAQs

      EMDRIA Credit FAQs

      EMDRIA Digital Badges

      Consultant / Trainer Events

  • Publications & Resources
    • Publications & Resources

      Search the EMDRIA Library
      Subscribe to our Blog

      Journal of EMDR Practice & Research®

      Go With That Magazine®

      Focal Point Blog

      Let's Talk EMDR Podcast

      EMDRIA Library

      Glossary of EMDR Terms

      Glossary of EMDR Terms

      Online EMDR Therapy Resources

      Online EMDR Therapy Resources

      Antiracism Resources

      Antiracism Resources

      Toolkits & Practice Resources

      Toolkits & Practice Resources

      Español: Recursos en Español

      Español: Recursos en Español

  • Publications & Resources
    • EMDRIA Library
    • Glossary of EMDR Terms
    • Antiracism Resources
    • Online EMDR Therapy Resources
    • Focal Point Blog
      • Subscribe to Focal Point Blog
    • Go With That Magazine®
    • Journal of EMDR Practice & Research®
    • Let’s Talk EMDR Podcast
    • Toolkits & Practice Resources
      • 8 Phases Toolkit
      • Building Your EMDR Practice Toolkit
      • Client Brochures
      • Addictions Toolkit
      • Depression Toolkit
      • EMDRIA Children’s Toolkit
      • Chronic Pain Toolkit
      • Military Toolkit
      • EMDR Consultation Toolkit
    • Kits y Recursos Prácticos
      • Folletos de Terapia EMDR
      • Kit de las 8 Fases
      • Kit de la Depresión
      • Kit del Dolor Crónico
      • Kit de los Niños y Niñas
  • Membership
    • Users_Group

      Membership

      Member Hub
      EMDRIA Member Connect

      Join EMDRIA

      Benefits of Membership

      Benefits of Membership

      Membership vs Certification

      Membership vs Certification

      Agency Group Membership

      Agency Group Membership

      International Affiliates

      International Affiliates

      Members Only

      Account Overview

      Account Overview

      Directory Profile Information

      Directory Profile Information

      Renew Membership

      Renew Membership

      Retired Membership

      Retired Membership

  • Membership
    • Join EMDRIAâ„¢
      • Retired Membership
      • Agency Group Membership
      • International Affiliate Organizations
    • Member Hub
    • Renew EMDRIAâ„¢ Membership
    • Membership Benefits
    • EMDRIAâ„¢ Member Account Overview
    • Directory Profile Information
    • Membership vs Certification
  • About EMDRIAâ„¢
    • Circle_Help

      About EMDRIAâ„¢

      EMDRIA Foundation

      About Us

      EMDRIA 30th Anniversary

      EMDRIA 30th Anniversary

      Policies & Code of Conduct

      Policies & Code of Conduct

      EMDRIA Awards & Winners

      EMDRIA Awards & Winners

      EMDRIA FAQs

      EMDRIA FAQs

      Meet the Board of Directors

      Board News and Updates

      Board News and Updates

      Contact Media Relations

      Contact EMDRIA

  • About EMDRIAâ„¢
    • EMDRIA’s 30th Anniversary
    • EMDRIAâ„¢ FAQs
    • Contact EMDRIAâ„¢
    • Contact Media Relations
    • Board News and Updates
      • Annual Membership Meeting
    • EMDR International Associationâ„¢ Policies
    • EMDRIAâ„¢ Awards & Winners
    • EMDRIA Foundation
Home / Resources / PTSD / Comparative efficacy and acceptability of psychotherapies for post-traumatic stress disorder in children and adolescents: A systematic review and network meta-analysis (BMJ Mental Health)

Share on social media

Comparative efficacy and acceptability of psychotherapies for post-traumatic stress disorder in children and adolescents: A systematic review and network meta-analysis (BMJ Mental Health)

Comparative efficacy and acceptability of psychotherapies for post-traumatic stress disorder in children and adolescents: A systematic review and network meta-analysis

A comparison and rank of the different types and formats of psychotherapies for PTSD in children and adolescents.


Article Abstract

“Background Available evidence on the comparative efficacy and acceptability of psychotherapies for post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) in children and adolescents remains uncertain.

Objective We aimed to compare and rank the different types and formats of psychotherapies for PTSD in children and adolescents.

Methods We searched eight databases and other international registers up to 31 December 2020. The pairwise meta-analyses and frequentist network meta-analyses estimated pooled standardised mean differences (SMDs) and ORs with random-effects model. Efficacy at post-treatment and follow-up, acceptability, depressive and anxiety symptoms were measured.

Findings We included 56 randomised controlled trials with 5327 patients comparing 14 different types of psychotherapies and 3 control conditions. For efficacy, cognitive processing therapy (CPT), behavioural therapy (BT), individual trauma-focused cognitive–behavioural therapy (TF-CBT), eye movement desensitisation and reprocessing, and group TF-CBT were significantly superior to all control conditions at post-treatment and follow-up (SMDs between −2.42 and −0.25). Moreover, CPT, BT and individual TF-CBT were more effective than supportive therapy (SMDs between −1.92 and −0.49). Results for depressive and anxiety symptoms were similar to the findings for the primary outcome. Most of the results were rated as ‘moderate’ to ‘very low’ in terms of confidence of evidence.

Conclusions CPT, BT and individual TF-CBT appear to be the best choices of psychotherapy for PTSD in young patients. Other types and different ways of delivering psychological treatment can be alternative options. Clinicians should consider the importance of each outcome and the patients’ preferences in real clinical practice.”

—Description from publisher

Article Access

Open Access

Xiang, Y., Cipriani, A., Teng, T., Del Giovane, C., Zhang, Y., Weisz, J. R., Li, X., Cuijpers, P., Liu, X., Barth, J., Jiang, Y., Cohen, D., Fan, L., Gillies, D., Du, K., Ravindran, A. V., Zhou, X., & Xie, P. (2021). Comparative efficacy and acceptability of psychotherapies for post-traumatic stress disorder in children and adolescents: A systematic review and network meta-analysis. BMJ Mental Health, 24, 153-160. Open access: http://dx.doi.org/10.1136/ebmental-2021-300346

View the Resource
Basic Info Collapse

Date
October 1, 2021

Creator(s)
Yajie Xiang, Andrea Cipriani, Teng Teng

Contributor(s)
Cinzia Del Giovane, Yuqing Zhang, John R. Weisz, Xuemei Li, Pim Cuijpers, Xueer Liu2, Jürgen Barth, Yuanliang Jiang, David Cohen, Li Fan, Donna Gillies, Kang Du, Arun V. Ravindran, Xinyu Zhou, Peng Xie

Topics
PTSD

Client Population
Adolescents, Children

More Info Collapse

Extent
7 pages

Publisher
BMJ Publishing Group LTD.

Rights
© BMJ Publishing Group Limited 2024.

APA Citation
Xiang, Y., Cipriani, A., Teng, T., Del Giovane, C., Zhang, Y., Weisz, J. R., Li, X., Cuijpers, P., Liu, X., Barth, J., Jiang, Y., Cohen, D., Fan, L., Gillies, D., Du, K., Ravindran, A. V., Zhou, X., & Xie, P. (2021). Comparative efficacy and acceptability of psychotherapies for post-traumatic stress disorder in children and adolescents: A systematic review and network meta-analysis. BMJ Mental Health, 24, 153-160. Open access: http://dx.doi.org/10.1136/ebmental-2021-300346

Audience
EMDR Therapists, Other Mental Health Professionals

Language
English

Content Type
Article, Meta-analyses/Systematic Reviews, Peer-Reviewed

Access Type
External Resource, Open Access

Related Resources

EMDR Therapy and Military Resource List

Read More

Comparative efficacy and acceptability of psychotherapies for panic disorder with or without agoraphobia: Systematic review and network meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials (BJPsych)

Read More

Trauma-focused psychotherapies for post-traumatic stress disorder: A systematic review and network meta-analysis (Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica)

Read More

Find an EMDR Therapist®

EMDRIAâ„¢ has more than 18,000 members trained to provide EMDR Therapy. Find a therapist near you.

Find an EMDR Therapist®
d2088683554149097441c3e1f6c13679941fbfdf (1)
EMDRIA

7000 N Mo Pac Expy
Ste 200
Austin, TX 78731-3013

info@emdria.org

512-451-5200

EMDRIA Facebook EMDRIA Twitter EMDRIA LinkedIn EMDRIA YouTube EMDRIA Online Community
  • About EMDR Therapy
  • EMDR Training and Education
  • EMDRIAâ„¢ Membership
  • Publications & Resources
  • EMDRIA Member Connect
  • EMDRIA Foundation
  • Privacy Policy
  • Copyright Policy
  • Accessibility Statement
  • Sitemap

© 1995-2026 EMDR International Association™. All rights reserved.

Website by Flipside Group

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
  • This field is hidden when viewing the form
  • This field is hidden when viewing the form
  • This field is hidden when viewing the form
  • This field is hidden when viewing the form
  • This field is hidden when viewing the form
  • Please be aware that email is not a secure means of communication and spam filters may prevent your email from reaching the therapist. We recommend you follow up with a phone call. Sending an email using this page does not guarantee that the recipient will receive, read, or respond to your email.

    If this is an emergency do not use this form. Call 911 or your nearest hospital.

We use cookies to ensure the best website experience. See our privacy policy to learn more.